Exor相对资产净值的大幅折价提供了不对称的投资机会,其潜在回报来自法拉利的复利增长以及最终资产净值的正常化。
逐段跳播
Exor肯定继续以相对于其资产净值的巨大折价进行交易。但只要Exor没有大幅缩小价格与价值之间的差距,并且只要法拉利一切顺利,我们真的看不到卖出这项业务的太多理由。
Xer is definitely continuing to trade at this massive discount to its net asset value. But as long as Exo doesn't drastically close the price and value gap, and as long as things are going well for Ferrari, we don't really see much of a reason to sell this business.
即使折价保持巨大,Exor的股票也会随着其资产净值的增加而上涨。下行风险是折价进一步扩大。但我认为,对于这种资产负债表上有真实且有价值的资产、无法完全注销的情况,折价要变得更宽将是前所未有的。
And even if it stays at a massive discount, well, Exor stock will increase as its NAV increases. The downside being that the discount widens even more. But I think it would be really unprecedented for the discount to get much wider for this type of situation where there are real valuable assets on the balance sheet that cannot be entirely written off.
所以我们之前说过,也许我们有点过早,但这仍然感觉像是一个不对称的赌注:我们不知道法拉利会发生什么,但在其他条件相同的情况下,我认为折价相对于资产净值长期来看可能只会朝一个方向移动。
So we said this before and you know we were maybe a little premature but it does still feel like an asymmetric bet here where we don't know what will happen with Ferrari but everything else being equal I think the discount to NAV can probably only move in one direction in the long term.
然后纯粹押注Exor的折价相对于资产净值收窄,如果你对法拉利并不真正感到兴奋,那作为一项投资就不那么有吸引力了,因为没有金融法则,没有金融引力要求市场完全认可Exor的资产净值,即使直觉上你可能会很合理地预期市场不必同意你的逻辑。
and then purely betting on the exor discount to nav to narrow it's just not nearly as attractive as an investment if you're not really excited about Ferrari because there's no law of finance there's no financial gravity that requires the markets to fully recognize exer's net asset value even if intuitively you would be pretty logical to expect that the market doesn't have to agree with your logic.
另一方面,对我来说,这里的吸引力在于有可能拥有两个引擎,通过法拉利的复利放大你的回报,而法拉利的复利一直非常非常好。此外,Exor 相对于资产净值的折价正在正常化。
And so on the flip side, what's so attractive about this to me is the possibility of having two twin engines magnifying your returns with Ferrari's compounding, which has been very, very good. Plus, Exer's discount to NAV normalizing.
仅此一项就可能翻倍。我认为这里的机会仍然相当有吸引力,尤其是从 Exor 的角度来看。但关于 Exor,我还想和你讨论另一个领域,那就是卖出标准。
That alone could be a double. I think the opportunity here is still quite compelling, especially looking at it from Exor's point of view. But there was one other area that I want to discuss with you, Sean, on exor, and that was kill criteria.
所以当我设定卖出标准时,它只需要两件事:一个状态和一个日期。通常,我会把日期设在大约一年后,尽管有时如果这是一个非常长期的押注,可能会更长。然后状态基本上基于几个关键绩效指标。
我认为这会完全破坏投资逻辑,以至于非常非常明显地表明我错了。
So when I do a kill criteria, I just it needs two things. It needs a state and a date. So, generally the date I put about a year out, although sometimes if it's a really long-term bet, it might be longer. And then the state is just based on pretty much a few KPIs. I think that would completely derail the thesis to a point where it's just very, very obvious that I'm wrong.
所以,我想向你提出这个问题:你需要看到 Exor 发生什么,才会完全破坏投资逻辑,以至于非常明显地表明我们可能需要卖出它?
So, I want to pose this question to you. What would you need to see happen in Exor that would completely derail the thesis to a point where it's just glaringly obvious that we probably need to sell it?
是的,我认为这是一个很好的问题,因为我们可以坐在这里整天用确认偏误来说服自己,为什么我们仍然觉得买入 Exor 是一个好决定。
Yeah, I think it's a great it's a great question because we can sit here and confirmation bias ourselves all day. into why it was a we still feel like it was a good decision to to buy into Exer.
但归根结底,如果我们是在进行这种开放式的押注,赌 Exor 的资产净值折价收窄,那我们就是在为一个未知时期的潜在痛苦签约,而这未必是一种好的投资实践。
Uh but at the end of the day, if we're sort of taking this open-ended bet on Exer's gap to NAV narrowing, we're signing up for an unknown period of potential pain and that's not necessarily a great investing practice.
所以,如果我们看到 Exor 做出非常糟糕的资本配置决策,那对我来说肯定是一个高层次的信号,表明这不值得麻烦,而且市场对其资本配置能力的悲观是有道理的,对吧?
And so if we were to see Exer make really poor allocation decisions, that would definitely be a signal at a high level to me that this just isn't worth the trouble and that the market was right to be pessimistic on their capital allocation ability, right?
这可能意味着,当他们有机会以大幅折价回购自己的股票时,却推迟回购,转而收购一些我们认为平庸的业务,甚至可能为此支付过高的价格。
And that what that could mean was maybe holding off on buybacks when they've had the chance to to buy their own shares at a massive discount in favor of acquiring some business that we deem to be mediocre and and then maybe overpaying for it.
那将非常令人失望,并且会再次验证市场的想法,即 Exor 理应相对于资产净值折价交易。另外,我们今天没有真正讨论到,但控制 Exor 的阿涅利家族有很多家庭纠纷,实际上母亲在起诉自己的儿子。这很丑陋。
That would be really disappointing and and that would validate again the market's thinking that Exer deserves to trade at a discount to NAV. And also, we didn't really talk about it today, but there's a lot of family drama with the Anellis who control Exer where you've got actually the mom suing her own son. And it's ugly stuff.
而且,这种可能性很低,因为诉讼似乎有些站不住脚。但如果我们确实看到约翰·埃尔坎出于某种原因失去对公司的控制权,或者被免去首席执行官职务,那在我看来,这将表明幕后发生的事情太多,以至于无法证明这项投资是合理的。
And well, it's a it's a low likelihood because the lawsuits do seem to be somewhat spurious. But if we did see John Elen lose control of the company for whatever reason or or be removed as CEO, I mean, that would be a sign that there's just too much going on behind the scenes to justify the investment in my opinion.
所以,密切关注背后的一些法律纠纷也是值得做的。这是 Exor 首席执行官约翰·埃尔坎的一句话:我学会了在逆境中不绝望,我也正在学习在顺境中不乐观。
And so keeping an eye actually on some of the legal dramas in the background here would also be worth doing. This one by Exor CEO John Elcat. I learned not to be desperate in bad times and I'm learning not to be bullish when times are good.
因此,鉴于 Exor 股价在过去一年下跌了 24%,我认为约翰正在践行他所说的话,没有做出任何过于鲁莽的举动。
So with Exor shares down 24% over the last year, I think John is practicing what he preaches by not making any overly erratic moves.
虽然市场在短期内肯定可能非常残酷,但如果 Exor 的资产净值继续以每年约 12% 的历史速度复利增长,那么股价在某个时候反弹的可能性相当大。
While the market can definitely be very punishing in the short term, if Exor's NAV continues to compound at its historical rate of about 12% annually, chances are pretty good that the shares will rebound at some point.
考虑到 Exor 过去凭借今天拥有的优秀资产所取得的一些非凡收益,我认为他今天采取了正确的做法,保持冷静,并继续为股东创造价值。
And with some of the extraordinary gains Exor has made in the past with some of the wonderful assets they have today, I think he's taken the right approach today to stay level-headed and to continue to provide shareholder value.
而今天,这正是我们将要探讨的:Exor,一家持有法拉利大量股份的控股公司。我们或许能以大幅折扣押注法拉利。
And today, that's exactly what we will be exploring with XR NB, a holding company with a significant stake in Ferrari. We might just be able to bet on Ferrari at a major discount.
他说在等什么
这个频道对 $EXR 的历次判断
The Intrinsic Value Podcast 在这只股票上只有这一条判断。