相较于 Archer Aviation,Joby Aviation 因其规模、现金状况以及基于 DCF 的上行空间而更受青睐。
逐段跳播
我最近上调了 Joby Aviation 和 Archer Aviation 股票的评级,并告知风险承受能力非常高的投资者,对这两家 EVTOL 公司而言,如今的风险回报比已经值得。
I recently upgraded the rankings on Joby Aviation and Archer Aviation stocks, informing investors with a very high risk tolerance that the risk versus reward is now worthwhile for these EVTOL companies.
但现在我不断被问到,在当前市场价格下,这两家 EVTOL 公司中哪一家是更好的投资。因此,从规模来看,Joby Aviation 拥有早期优势,其过去 12 个月营收为 1.16 亿美元,而 Archer Aviation 仅为 690 万美元。
But now I'm getting the question, which one of these two EVTOL companies is the better investment at current market prices? So when we're looking at scale, Joby Aviation has the early advantage with $116 million in trailing 12-month revenue compared to just 6.9 million for Archer Aviation.
当然,这一格局在未来 12 到 24 个月内将发生巨大变化,因为这两家公司都达成了重大交易并进行了大规模收购,这将使 Joby Aviation 的营收几乎翻倍,
Of course, this equation is going to change dramatically over the next 12 to 24 months as these two have made big deals and made huge acquisitions that will nearly double Joby Aviation's revenue,
然而,展望未来,这些业务的核心品类——EVTOL——仍处于早期阶段,正在获取监管批准、测试技术、向监管机构证明其安全性,并证明它确实能实现他们所宣称的功能,同时与监管机构合作,在他们给出反馈时调整技术、采纳反馈等等。
Looking forward, however, the core category of these businesses, the EVTOL, they're still in the early stages getting regulatory approval, testing the technology, proving to regulators that it's safe, and it delivers indeed what they say it delivers, working with regulators when they give them feedback, adjusting their technology, incorporating the feedback, etc.
这将是一个来回反复的过程,可能需要一段时间,这两家公司的 EVTOL 才能在全球范围内广泛投入使用。而这一机会是巨大的。
It's going to be a back-and-forth process that could take a while before these two have working EVTOLs broadly available across the world. And the opportunity is huge.
全球有许多城市拥有人口密集的市场,这意味着高峰时段的交通可能让你在 20 英里半径内花上一个半小时才能到达工作地点。
Uh the number of cities around the world with markets that are densely populated, meaning rush hour traffic could cause you to take, you know, an hour and a half to get to work in a 20-mi radius.
因此那里的机会是巨大的。人们愿意支付溢价来使用这项技术出行,并让在这些可能让你被困数小时的时间段里出门上路变得可行。
And so the opportunity there is huge. People would be willing to pay a premium price to access this technology to travel and make it accessible to go on the road and leave your home during these hours that could cause you to be stuck for several hours.
当我做出这些评级上调、将这些股票列为买入机会时,我提醒投资者,这些都是亏损企业。现金消耗巨大。但 Joby Aviation 在这方面同样更为领先,其经营活动现金流为 -500%,而 Archer Aviation 为 -7,800%。
Now, when I made these upgrades and ranked these stocks as buying opportunities, I warned investors that these are money-losing enterprises. Significant cash burn. But Joby Aviation is further ahead in this regard as well, -500% in cash flow from operations compared to -7,800% for Archer Aviation.
对于许多仍在努力开发技术以使其广泛可用的早期公司来说,这是一个普遍现象。如果它们实现了宏大的抱负,目前的规模只是其未来规模的一小部分。
And this is a common theme for many early-stage companies that are still trying to develop the technology to make it broadly available. These are at a fraction of the scale that they will be if they achieve their grand ambitions.
但对投资者来说,那是一个巨大的拐点。当一家公司达到——当一家早期公司终于达到至少在现金流层面实现盈亏平衡的水平时,那才是更重要的数字。
But for investors, that's a huge inflection point. When a company hits when an early-stage company finally gets to a level where they're at least breaking even in terms of cash flow, that's the more important figure.
很多时候投资者看的是净利润率或其他利润率层面的盈亏平衡,但这些都不如现金流重要,因为现金流决定了这些公司是否需要去找投资者要更多钱。
A lot of times investors look at, you know, breaking even in terms of net profit margin or another profit margin, but those are not as important as the cash flow because that determines if these companies need to go to investors and ask for more money.
如果你有盈利,但现金流仍为负,那不如现金流为正、但利润仍为负来得有效。这正说明了会计体系的复杂性。在美国,有很多非现金支出,比如股权激励、折旧和摊销,它们会模糊利润表和现金流量表,
If you're profitable, but you're still negative in cash flow, that's not as effective as being positive in cash flow, but still negative in terms of profits. And this just goes to the complexities of the accounting system.
In the United States, there are a lot of non-cash expenses like stock-based compensation, depreciation, and amortization that muddle the income statement and the cash flow statement,
但我鼓励投资者,在评估早期公司、评估那些仍在增长且未来前景仍然广阔的公司时,要看现金流量表,把它置于利润表之上,因为这才是公司需要去找投资者要更多资本的地方。
but I encourage investors when you're when you're evaluating early-stage companies and where you're evaluating companies that are still growing and still have large prospects for the future, look at the cash flow statement, prioritize that over the income statement because this is where the company will need to go to investors and ask for more capital.
而如果他们不得不在绝望的处境下这么做,就不得不接受更差的条款才能从投资者那里拿到更多钱。反之,如果一家公司能够自我维持,至少在经营活动现金流与销售额之比上实现盈亏平衡,那么它就可以更有耐心。
它只在合适的时机去找投资者,在市场情绪狂热、价格高企、利率低的时候。
And if they have to do that in a desperate situation, they're going to have to accept worse terms in order to get more money from investors. Whereas, if a company is, you know, self-sustaining, you know, they're they're at least breaking even in terms of cash flow from operations to sales, then they can be more patient.
They can only go to investors at opportune moments, at moments when there's euphoria in the stock market, when prices are elevated, when interest rates are low.
他们可以择机把握时机,在那些时刻获取资本,而不是在可能陷入绝境、别无选择、只能接受投资者开出的条件时才发现需要资本,而投资者在那种时刻可不会仁慈。
They can time it opportunistically to get capital at those moments rather than needing capital perhaps in a desperate situation where they don't have the choice and they have to accept the terms offered by investors and investors are not kind in those moments.
如果一家公司陷入绝境来找他们,他们确实会尽量把收取的利率最大化。所以同样地,评估它们的资产负债表很重要。要看它们银行里有多少现金,相对于有多少债务,以及有多少利息支出。
They really try to maximize the rate of interest charged if a company comes to them in a desperate situation. So in that same regard, evaluating their balance sheet is important.
Looking at how much cash they have in the bank versus how much debt they have and how much interest expense they have.
所幸的是,这两家公司的债务水平都非常低,所以这里重要的是银行账户里的现金。Joby Aviation 同样是现金更多。银行账户里有 22.6 亿美元的现金及短期投资,相比之下 Archer Aviation 为 15.68 亿美元。
And thankfully, these two, they have very low levels of debt and so the cash in the bank account is the important thing here. Joby Aviation, again, more cash. $2.26 billion in cash and short-term investments in the bank account compared to Archer Aviation with $1.568 billion.
所以它们银行账户里都有一笔可观的资本。它们能够在市场狂热和亢奋的时刻抓住机会,以高估值卖出股票,从而充实了资产负债表,它们有很长的跑道、充足的时间去实现下一个里程碑,
So they both have a robust sum of capital in the bank account. They were able to capitalize during moments of frenzy and euphoria in the market and sell stock at elevated valuations and so shored up their balance sheets and they've got a long runway, a lot of time to hit their next milestone,
去达到下一个水平,届时它们就可以回头找投资者说:“看,我们已经实现了这个下一个里程碑。我们现在风险更小了。因为我们已经达到了这个水平,我们现在风险更低了,投资者也会更愿意以更有吸引力的条件给它们提供资本。”
to hit that next level when they can then go back to investors and say, "Look, we've hit this next milestone. We're now less risk. We're now lower risk because we've achieved this level and investors would be even more willing to give them capital at more attractive terms.
有趣的是,当我们用远期市销率来衡量时,它们的估值非常接近。Archer Aviation 为 29.6,Joby Aviation 为 28.7。
And interestingly, they're selling at very similar valuations when we measure on a forward price to sales ratio. Archer Aviation at 29.6, Joby Aviation at 28.7.
由于这些投资高风险、高回报的性质,你几乎可以说这是平局。安全边际需要更宽。我还为这两家公司计算了现金流折现估值,用这种估值方法衡量,它们看起来被低估了。
You can almost call this a tie because of the high risk, high reward nature of these investments. The margin of safety needs to be wider. I also calculated a discounted cash flow valuation for these two companies and they look undervalued when measuring using this valuation method.
同样地,我计算出 Joby Aviation 的公允价值为 8.80 美元。当前市场价格为 6.34 美元,所以我计算出 Joby Aviation 在未来 12 到 18 个月大约有 39% 的上涨空间。
Similarly, I calculated a fair value of Joby Aviation at $8.80. The current market price is $6.34, so I calculated roughly 39% upside over the next 12 to 18 months with Joby Aviation.
当然,如果你看得更长远,上涨空间要大得多。所以,我喜欢 Archer 和 Joby 的风险回报比。在当前这些价位上它们看起来有吸引力。
And of course, much larger upside if you look at it much longer term. So, I like the risk versus reward for Archer and Joby. They look attractive at these levels.
如果我只能选一个,我会选 Joby Aviation,因为它的规模更大、资产负债表更强,而且用现金流折现模型评估时上涨空间更好。
If I had to pick only one, I would pick Joby Aviation because of the larger scale, the stronger balance sheet, and the better upside when evaluating using a discounted cash flow model.
但请记住,这些只应考虑给风险承受能力非常非常高的投资者。这些是非常高风险的投资,长期来看有爆发性回报的潜力。
But remember, these should only be considered for investors with a very, very high risk tolerance. These are very high risk investments with the potential for explosive returns in the long run.
这个频道对 $JOBY 的历次判断
Parkev Tatevosian, CFA 在这只股票上共 2 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。