$MU

MU 值得买入,目标价 1,395 美元,较现价有 36% 上行空间,但因护城河较弱及 2028 年定价风险,其偏好度低于 NVDA。

看涨他说的是几个月内
《Should You Buy Micron Stock Instead of Nvidia? | MU Stock vs. NVDA Stock》
Parkev Tatevosian, CFA发布 2026-09-13 · 33 段内容
00:00/ 打开原视频

逐段跳播

33 段内容
0:0015:26

Nvidia 和 Micron 是从创建数据中心的支出大幅增长中受益最多的两家公司。Micron 在最近一个已完成的季度中,营收较去年同期增长了 4 倍以上,而 Nvidia 的营收已飙升至接近 3030 亿美元。

Nvidia and Micron are two of the companies benefiting most from the huge increase in spending on creating data centers. Micron's revenue increased by more than 4 x in its most recently completed quarter from the same time last year, while Nvidia's revenues have soared to approach $303 billion.

但这两者中,哪一只在当前市场价格下更值得买入?这就是我想在本视频中通过将两者正面比较来回答的问题。自 2023 年以来,Nvidia 的业务蓬勃发展,而更近一段时间 Micron 的业务也在蓬勃发展。

你可以看到 Nvidia 的销售在 2023 年蓬勃发展,飙升,在营收上超过了 Micron。它们的营收在 2022 年很接近,事实上在 2022 年之前那十年的大部分时间里,Micron 创造的营收都高于 Nvidia。

But which one of these two is the better stock to buy at current market prices? That's the question I want to answer in this video by comparing the two head to head. Since 2023 business is booming for Nvidia and for more recently business is booming for Micron.

You can see Nvidia's sales boom in 2023, soaring, surpassing Micron in revenues. Their revenues were close in 2022 and in fact for the better part of the previous decade before 2022, Micron generated more revenue than Nvidia.

但近年来你可以看到,自 2023 年以来,Nvidia 的营收已经飙升,现在已是 Micron 的三倍多。

But in recent years you can see since 2023, Nvidia's revenues have soared and it's now more than triple that of Micron.

Micron 的营收在更近一段时间有所增长,受益于内存价格飙升,因为智能体 AI 的普及使内存和存储变得重要得多。Micron 在最近一个滚动 12 个月期间的营收增长至超过 900 亿美元,而 Nvidia 的营收正接近 3030 亿美元。

Micron's revenue has increased more recently benefiting from soaring prices for memory as the proliferation of agentic AI has made memory and storage that much more important. Micron's revenues increased to over $90 billion in the most recent trailing 12-month period, while Nvidia's are approaching $303 billion.

展望未来,预计 Micron 和 Nvidia 至少还会再有两三年,很可能至少三年,实现显著的营收增长。这些公司签署的合同已经延伸到未来两三年之后,因为购买这些技术使得在自身需求之前锁定供应变得更加紧迫。

因此,Nvidia 和 Micron 对其销售情况有了更高的可见度,不仅是 2026 年,还有 2027 年和 2028 年,Micron 告知投资者它签署了战略客户协议,一直延伸到 2030 年。这是一个新的进展。

Looking forward, Micron and Nvidia are expected to generate significant revenue growth for at least a couple of more years, probably three more years at the least. The contracts that these companies have signed have extended beyond these next couple of years as the purchases of these technologies have made it more urgent to secure supply ahead of their needs.

And so, Nvidia and Micron have more visibility into what their sales look like, not just for 2026, but also for 2027 and 2028, with Micron informing investors that it signed strategic customer agreements that are spanning all the way out until 2030. This is a new development.

通常情况下,Nvidia 和 Micron 会在产品推出的当年就将其售出,相关协议与技术的买方只有松散的联系。但由于出现了严重的短缺,而且 Nvidia 和 Micron 的产品已经售罄好几年了,技术的买方正在提前规划,为 Micron 和 Nvidia 锁定未来许多年的协议。

这对 Nvidia 和 Micron 来说是好消息。这让它们的业务更易于管理。如果它们知道客户明年和后年想要什么,就能相应地做规划。它们可以与供应商合作,可以与供应链合作,确保有足够的产品来满足需求。

这降低了研发的风险。它们知道自己该研发什么样的产品,因为它们与最大的客户有沟通,客户会告诉它们自己在寻找什么。这一切对 Nvidia 和 Micron 来说都非常有利。

Typically, Nvidia and Micron sell their products in the year they're launched with agreements loosely connected to the buyers of the technology. But, since there's been significant shortages, and Nvidia's and Micron's products have been sold out for a couple of years now, buyers of the technology are planning ahead, securing agreements for Micron and Nvidia for many years into the future.

That's good news for Nvidia and Micron. It makes their business more manageable. If they know what their customers want next year and the year after that, they can plan accordingly.

They can work with their suppliers. They can work with their supply chain and make sure that they have enough product to meet that demand. It lowers the risk for research and development.

They know what kind of products to research and development because they have conversations with their biggest customers, and their customers inform them what they'll be looking for. That's all been great for Nvidia and Micron.

更令人印象深刻的是,这些公司一直在以旺盛的利润率创造旺盛的销售额。事实上,Micron 在最近一个已完成的季度的营业利润率超过了 80%。这是我在过去十年里跟踪过的任何其他公司身上都没见过的。这是我第一次见到营业利润率超过 80%。

Now, to make matters more impressive, these companies have been generating booming sales with booming profit margins. In fact, Micron's operating profit margin in the most recently completed quarter exceeded 80%.

It's something I haven't seen with any other company that I've been following in the previous decade. It's the first time I've ever seen an operating profit margin above 80%.

从过去 12 个月的口径来看,Micron 的营业利润率升至 65.75%,超过了 Nvidia。

Looking at it on a trailing 12-month basis, Micron's operating profit margin ticked above Nvidia at 65.75%

这些都是极佳的营业利润率,直到最近,Visa 一直是营业利润率最高的公司,在 60% 区间,而 Nvidia、Micron 以及其他几家公司如今在半导体需求旺盛的推动下正接近这样的盈利水平。

These are excellent operating profit margins and until recently Visa had been the company with the highest operating profit margin in the 60% range and Nvidia, Micron, and a few other companies are now approaching these levels of profitability given booming demand for semiconductors.

对于 Nvidia,我认为其 60% 区间的营业利润率比 Micron 更具可持续性。不过,短期内,我认为 Micron 的营业利润率很可能会超过 Nvidia,大概在未来 12 个月。

Now, for Nvidia I think it's operating profit margin in the 60% range is more sustainable than Micron. However, in the short run, I believe Micron's operating profit margin will likely exceed Nvidia's probably for the next 12 months.

在未来 24 个月里这样假设也是合理的,因为 Micron 正以更高的价格销售其产品。Micron 在未来 12 到 24 个月里有更大的灵活性来提高其产品价格。

Uh it would be reasonable to assume over the next 24 months as well because Micron is selling its products at higher prices. Micron has more flexibility to increase prices in its products over the next 12 to 24 months.

不过,从更长期来看,与 Nvidia 相比,Micron 在创造更高平均售价方面的灵活性更小,而 Nvidia 拥有更强的竞争优势、更强的议价能力,相对而言能将其价格维持在当前水平。

所以,对于 Micron,存在一种风险:也许从现在起 2 年或 3 年后,当存储和内存市场的供需格局改善时,Micron 的单位价格会下跌。

However, looking longer term, Micron has less flexibility to generate those higher average selling prices compared to Nvidia, which has more competitive advantage, more negotiating power to sustain its prices at where they're at, relatively speaking.

So, with Micron, there's a risk that maybe 2 years from now or 3 years from now when the supply demand dynamics improve in the storage and memory markets, that Micron's price per unit will drop.

即便价格下跌,Micron 的管理团队已经签订了这些协议,在其战略客户协议中,单位价格能下跌的水平有一个下限。

And even if it drops, Micron's management team has these agreements in place where there's a floor to the level that the price per unit can drop in its strategic customer agreements.

所以,这两家公司的利润率很可能会在至少未来 12 个月里保持高位,可能未来 24 个月,然后我们会开始听到未来 36 个月和 48 个月的前景会是什么样子。

So, profit margins are likely to stay elevated for at least the next 12 months for these two, probably the next 24 months, and then we'll start to hear about what the prospects look like 36 and 48 months into the future.

正如我之前提到的,这就是这些公司接下来的大事。我们对这些公司的需求和供给获得了越来越多的可见性。我们现在会展望未来两三年,因为我们知道它们未来 12 个月已经售罄。我们知道它们未来 24 个月很可能也已售罄。

所以现在我们考虑的是未来三年、未来四年、未来五年。

And that's been the next big thing with these companies as I mentioned earlier. We're getting more and more visibility into demand and supply for these companies. We're now looking two or three years into the future because we know that they're sold out for the next 12 months.

We know that they're probably sold out for the next 24 months. So now we're thinking about three years into the future, four years into the future, five years into the future.

这两家公司的情况会是什么样子?对许多投资者来说,这方面有很多担忧,因为现在正在建设的所有这些数据中心,人们担心存在过度建设。而在某个时点,这些数据中心容量的使用者将不再需要所有这些过剩的需求。

What's the situation going to look like for these two? And for many investors, there's a lot of concern about that because all of these data centers that are being built right now, there's concern that there's overbuilding.

And at a certain point, those consumers of the capacity in these data centers will no longer need all of that excess demand.

所以投资者会担心需求会出现大幅下滑。不是今年,不是明年,因为那些协议大体上已经到位,但也许从现在起三年后,也许从现在起四年后,Nvidia 和 Micron 会不会经历销售额的大幅下滑?可以肯定,这是一种风险。

And so there will be investors are concerned that there will be a big drop-off in demand. Not this year, not next year, because those agreements are largely in place, but maybe three years from now, maybe four years from now, will Nvidia and Micron experience a big drop-off in sales? And that's a risk, to be sure.

但投资者可以感到宽慰的一点是,这些从 2023 年开始建设的数据中心,其中的组件将需要更换和升级,对吧?当我们展望未来两年时,我们看的是 2028 年、2029 年。所以那些 2022 年和 2023 年就在数据中心里的组件,将会变得过时,需要更换。

这样 Nvidia 和 Micron 就能从更换周期中创造收入。所以每一年都会有来自那些需要更换的过时产品的需求。

But one thing investors can take comfort in is these data centers that were built starting in 2023, those components will need to be replaced and upgraded, right? When we look two years into the future, we're going to be looking into 2028, 2029.

So those components that are in data centers from 2022 and 2023, those will be getting outdated and they'll need to be replaced. So then Nvidia and Micron can generate revenue from the replacement cycle.

So each and every year there's going to be demand from those outdated products that need to be replaced.

但这足以将收入维持在这些水平吗?这是最大的问号,还有利润率能否维持在这些水平。所以,就像它们的营业利润率一样,它们的投入资本回报率正在大幅提升,而我会说这是不可持续的。

But will that be enough to sustain revenues at these levels? That's the big question mark and profit margins at these levels. So, just like their operating profit margins, their returns on invested capital are improving dramatically and I would say unsustainably.

而 Micron 则拥有位于美国及世界各地的制造设施。因此,它每年都需要在制造产能和提升制造技术上投入数十亿美元。所以,它能创造的投入资本回报率的上行空间更低,而下行空间也更低、要糟糕得多。

Whereas Micron, it owns the manufacturing facilities in the United States and around the world. And so, it needs to invest billions of dollars in manufacturing capacity and improving the manufacturing technology each and every year.

So, it has a lower upside in terms of how much return on invested capital it can generate and a lower much worse downside as well.

所以,Micron 的投入资本回报率也在飙升至 63%。非常出色,但我认为同样不可持续。如果 Micron 能在多年时间里创造 40% 的投入资本回报率,那将为股东带来可观的价值。

如果它能达到 63% 或以上,那就是锦上添花。好消息是,在未来 12 到 24 个月里,Micron 很可能实现高水平的 ROIC,因为产品售价远高于 Micron 的预期,也远高于行业的预期。

所以,至少在未来 12 到 24 个月里,利润将非常出色。

So, Micron's return on invested capital is also soaring at 63%. Excellent, but also I think unsustainable. If Micron can generate a 40% return on invested capital for a duration of multiple years, that'll add significant value to shareholders.

If it can achieve 63% or above, that's icing on the cake. The good news is over the next 12 to 24 months, Micron's likely to return a elevated level of ROIC because the products are selling at such such higher prices than Micron was expecting and the industry was expecting.

So, the profits will be excellent for at least the next 12 to 24 months.

好,我们看了业绩表现、收入、盈利能力、投入资本回报率。对 Micron 和 Nvidia 来说,出色、出色、出色。正如我提到的,它们正从数据中心以及进入这些数据中心的组件的旺盛需求中显著受益。

All right, so we looked at performance, revenue, profitability, returns on invested capital. Excellent, excellent, and excellent for Micron and Nvidia. As I mentioned, they're benefiting significantly from the booming demand for data centers and the components that are going into those data centers.

Nvidia 的远期市盈率为 14.5。这是一个相对便宜的估值。正如我之前提到的,投资者担心 Nvidia 和 Micron 的收入和利润会断崖式下跌。不是今年,不是明年,而是从 2028 年开始,也许 2029 年。

投资者群体中存在一种明显的担忧,即收入和利润会断崖式下跌。因此,Nvidia 和 Micron 的估值正在计入这一风险。Nvidia 的远期市盈率仅为 14.5。

Nvidia is trading at a forward price to earnings of 14.5. This is a relatively cheap valuation. As I mentioned earlier, investors are concerned that revenue and profits are going to fall off a cliff for Nvidia and Micron.

Not this year, not next year, but starting 2028, maybe 2029. There is a palatable concern from the investor community that revenue and profits are going to fall off a cliff. And so, valuations for Nvidia and Micron are accounting for that risk.

Nvidia is selling at a forward price to earnings of just 14.5.

Costco 的远期市盈率几乎是 Nvidia 的三倍,也许是 Micron 的六到七倍,对吧?而这些公司的增长速度远不及 Nvidia 和 Micron 的增长速度,创造的利润率也远达不到这些水平。

Costco is selling at a forward PE that's almost triple Nvidia, and maybe six or seven times Micron, right? And these These companies that are not growing anywhere near the rates that Nvidia and Micron are growing or generating profit margins anywhere near these levels.

所以,这正好说明了围绕 Nvidia 和 Micron 的恐惧因素,以及这种恐惧有多少已经反映在估值里了。这并不是投资者掉以轻心的事情,对吧?

So, that just puts into context the fear factor with Nvidia and Micron and how much it's baked into the valuation already. It's not something that investors are complacent about, right?

在 Nvidia 和 Micron 身上,我看不到太多这种情况。与市场上的平均股票相比,与这些公司所产生的利润、盈利和利润率相比,它们的估值相对便宜。

I don't see very much of that with Nvidia and Micron. The valuations are relatively cheap compared to the average stock in the market, compared to the profits and earnings and profit margins that these companies are generating.

相比之下,Micron 的售价不到 Nvidia 的一半。我认为这是合理的。正如我之前提到的,我认为 Nvidia 的竞争优势比 Micron 更持久。Micron 的存储和内存产品与 SK Hynix、Samsung 等竞争对手并没有太大的差异化。

事实上,在 HBM 方面,Micron 落后于 SK Hynix。

Comparatively, Micron is selling at less than half the price of Nvidia. And I think that's justified. I as I mentioned earlier, I think Nvidia's competitive advantages are more durable than Micron.

Micron's memory and storage products are not all that differentiated from competitors like SK Hynix and Samsung. In fact, Micron in HBM is trailing SK Hynix.

而 Nvidia 是加速计算领域的绝对领导者,它向客户交付的 AI 工厂既包含软件也包含硬件。所以,我觉得 Nvidia 的竞争优势更持久,其售价也更可持续,而 Micron 则是在短期内受益于供需状况。

一旦这一状况得到修正,预测显示 2028 年将是我们开始看到内存和存储市场更加平衡的一年。2026 年、2027 年可能仍对 Micron 有利,但 2028 年或许会达到更好的均衡。

Whereas Nvidia is the absolute leader in accelerated computing, in the AI factory that it delivers to its customers with the software along with the hardware. So, I feel Nvidia's competitive advantages are more durable, its selling price more sustainable, whereas Micron is benefiting in the short term from the supply demand situation.

Which as soon as that corrects, estimates suggest that 2028 will be the year where we'll start to see a more balanced memory and storage market. 2026, 2027 likely still benefiting Micron, but 2028 perhaps a better equilibrium.

但对 Nvidia 来说,它受益的不只是供需动态。它受益是因为它的产品,它整体的产品组合,至少领先竞争对手一步。有些人会认为至少领先竞争对手两步。所以我觉得它更持久,因此在按远期市盈率衡量时,它理应比 Micron 享有更高的估值溢价。

But for Nvidia, it's not benefiting from only the supply-demand dynamics. It's benefiting because its product its holistic product offering is at least one step ahead of the competition.

And some would argue at least two steps ahead of the competition. And so I feel it's more durable and so it deserves a more premium valuation compared to Micron when measuring on a forward PE basis.

对于 Micron,我计算出的公允价值为 1,395 美元,而市场价格为 1,024 美元。按当前市场价格计算,我算出 Micron 股票有 36% 的上涨空间。

So with Micron, I calculated a fair value of $1,395 compared to the market price of $1,024. I calculated an upside of 36% on Micron stock at current market prices.

对于 Nvidia,我计算出的公允价值为 338 美元。当前市场价格为 224 美元,这意味着 Nvidia 有超过 50% 的上涨空间。所以,按 DCF 衡量时,Nvidia 股票看起来比 Micron 股票更被低估。

此外,按远期市盈率衡量,我觉得 Nvidia 的估值溢价因其更持久的竞争优势而合理。

For Nvidia, I calculated a fair value of $338. A current market price at $224 leaves over 50% upside for Nvidia. So when measuring on a DCF basis, Nvidia stock looks more undervalued than Micron stock.

Additionally, on a forward PE basis, I feel Nvidia's premium valuation is justified by the more durable competitive advantage.

但当然,我们还会了解到更多关于 Micron 的情况。Micron 定于 9 月底公布季度财务业绩。我将进行直播来解读这些业绩。

But of course, we're going to learn more about Micron. Micron is scheduled to report quarterly financial results at the end of September. I'm going to be going live to cover those results.

所以,如果我必须在这两者之间,在 Micron 或 Nvidia 之间,选择按当前市场价格更值得买入的股票,我会选 Nvidia。在这些市场价格下,对我来说这会是一个相对容易的决定。

事实上,我的投资组合里就持有 Nvidia 股票。根据当天的价格走势,它会在 Nvidia 和 Netflix 之间波动,成为我投资组合中的头号持仓。所以,我可能有点偏见,但我有偏见是因为我的研究把我引向了这个方向,让我选择了 Nvidia 而非 Micron。

它们两家都很优秀。我把它们都列为买入机会,但如果我必须只选一个,我会选 Nvidia。

So, if I had to pick between these two, Micron or Nvidia as the better stock to buy at current market prices, I would pick Nvidia. And it would be a relatively easy decision for me compared at these market prices.

In fact, I own Nvidia stock in my portfolio. It fluctuates between Nvidia and Netflix as my top position in my portfolio depending on the price action in the day. So, I might be a little biased, but I'm biased because my research has pointed me in that direction where I've chosen Nvidia over Micron.

They're both excellent. I have them both ranked as buying opportunities, but if I had to pick only one, I would pick Nvidia.

观察点

季度财务业绩
实际公布的业绩数据与市场预期的对比
9月底财报
业绩强劲则支撑看涨逻辑;业绩或指引疲软则可能削弱该逻辑。

这个频道对 $MU 的历次判断

Parkev Tatevosian, CFA 在这只股票上共 3 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。

2026-09-13看涨本条
Nvidia 和 Micron 是从创建数据中心的支出大幅增长中受益最多的两家公司。
2026-09-10看涨
跟踪 Micron 的华尔街分析师预测,该公司的每股收益将从截至 2024 年 8 月的财年的 1.23 美元,一路飙升至截至 2028 年 8 月的财年的 171 美元。
原话 00:00 ›
看完整历史 ›
美股听风